You are here

Meniscal Tear S83.209A 836.0

Flap Meniscal Tear picture

meniscal tear classifcation

ICD-9 Classification / Treatment
Etiology / Natural History Associated Injuries / Differential Diagnosis
Anatomy Complications
Clinical Evaluation Follow-up Care
Xray / Diagnositc Tests Review References

synonyms: meniscal tear, meniscus tear

Meniscal Tear ICD-10

Meniscal Tear ICD-9

  • 717.0 old bucket handle tear of medial meniscus
  • 717.1=derangement of anterior horn of medial meniscus
  • 717.2=derangement of posterior horn of medial meniscus
  • 717.3=other and unspecified derangement of medial meniscus
  • 717.4=derangement of lateral meniscus
  • 717.40=derangement of lateral meniscus unspecified
  • 717.41=bucket handle tear of lateral meniscus
  • 717.42=derangement of anterior horn of lateral meniscus
  • 717.43=derangement of posterior horn of lateral meniscus
  • 717.49=other and unspecified derangement of lateral meniscus
  • 717.5=derangement of meniscus, not elsewhere classified (congenital discoid meniscus, etc)
  • 836.0 (tear of medial cartilage or meniscus, current)
  • 836.1 (tear of lateral cartilage or meniscus, current)

Meniscal Tear Etiology / Epidemiology / Natural History

  • Most common knee injury
  • Higher risk in ACL deficient knees
  • Medial tears 3 times more common than lateral
  • Risks of progressive arthritis are proportional to amount of meniscus removed.
  • Traumatic tears generally caused by axial loading with rotation of a flexed knee.
  • Male > female.

Meniscal Tear Anatomy

  • Medial meniscus: C-shaped; anterior horn attaches ?; posterior horn attaches anterior to the insertion of the posterior cruciate ligament. (Johnson DL, Arthroscopy 1995;11:386) Average length = 45.7mm (McDermott ID, Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2004;12:130). Secondary stabilizer to anterior tibial translation.
  • Lateral Menisus: semicircular; anterior horn attaches adjacent to the ACL; posterior horn attaches behind the intracondylar eminence.(Johnson DL, Arthroscopy 1995;11:386) Average length = 35.7mm (McDermott ID, Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2004;12:130).
  • Discoid variant of the lateral meniscus is found in 3.5% to 5% of patients. (Vandermeer RD, Arthroscopy 1989;5:101)
  • Average excursions of the menisci with knee flexion = 5.2 mm for the medial and 11 mm for the lateral meniscus. (Thompson WO, AJSM 1991;19:210)
  • Provides shock absorption and attenuation of axial loads on the articular cartilage of the distal femur and proximal tibia. Secondary roles in knee stability, proprioception, joint lubrication and stress distribution.
  • Medial meniscus transmits 50% of the load in the medial compartment. Lateral meniscus transmits 70% of the load in the lateral compartment. (Greis PE, JAAOS 2002;10:168). Degenerative changes occur earlier in pts undergoing parital lateral meniscectomy than partial medial meniscectomy. Menisci transmit more load in flexion (85%) than in extention (50%).
  • Blood supply: the outer (peripheral) 20-30% of the medial meniscus and 10-25% of the lateral meniscus has blood supplied from the perimeniscal capillary plexus off the superior and inferior medial and lateral genicular arteries. (Arnoczky SP, AJSM 1982;10:90)
  • Medial and lateral menisci are attached by the transverse (intermeniscal) ligament and posteriorly by the coronary ligaments
  • 65% Water: 90% of collagen is type 1.
  • see also Medvecky MJ, JAAOS 2005;13:121

Meniscal Tear Clinical Evaluation

  • Pain and swelling in the knee. May have locking / catching / clicking sensation or giving way.
  • May be associated with a twisting injury.
  • Localized tenderness along the joint line.
  • McMurray test: patient lying supine with the hip and knee flexed 90°. Apply axial compression while ER and IR the leg. Reproduction of pain +/- clicking indicates meniscal tear.
  • Apley Compression Test
  • Ege's test
  • Note.

Meniscal Tear Xray / Diagnostic Tests

  • Knee xrays are generally normal but are indicated to evaluate for arthritis and rule out concomitant disorders.
  • MRI: tears and intrasubstance degeneration appear as marked increased signal on T1 and intermediate weighted images that is less prominent on T2 images. Grade 1 = poorly defined globular zone of increased signal. Grade 2 = a linear zone of hyperintensity not communicating with free meniscal surface. Grade 3 = a linear band of hyperintensity commonicating with a freee meniscal surface. (Stoller DW, Radiology 1988;166:580). Extrusion of the meniscus, defined as >3mm measured from the outer magrin of the meniscus to the outer articular margin of the medial tibial plateau on mid coronal MRI scans, is associated with posterior horn avulsion/meniscal root tear (Marzo JM, JAAOS 2009;17:276).
  • MRI Insurance Indications:  acute injury with mechanical symptoms (locking, popping).  Chronic mechanical symptoms that has failed 4 weeks of PT, or has mechanical symptoms in which an intraarticular loose body in the differential diagnosis.  
  • “Double PCL” sign indicates a displaced bucket-handle tear of the medial meniscus into the intercondylar notch. Bucket-handle tear of the lateral meniscus generally appears in the anterior aspect of the lateral compartment.

Meniscal Tear Classification / Treatment

  • Classification: longitudinal, bucket handle, flap, radial, horizontal cleavage, Complex/degenerative. Meniscal root avulsion.
  • Vascularity: red-red(within 3mm of meniscosynovial juntion) vs red-white(3mm-5mm from meniscosynovial junction) vs white-white(>5mm from meniscosynovial junction)
  • Treatment: depends on tear pattern and location, see specific tear type.
  • Non-op: activity modification or elimination of painful activities, ice, compression anti-inflammatory or analgesic medications. Weight loss in obese patients. Consider soft shock-absorbing shoe wear, medial-post orthotics, or valgus unloader brace. (Marzo JM, JAAOS 2009;17:276)
  • Partial Meniscectomy: 94.8% Good/excellent results for isolated meniscal tear, 62% good/excellent results for patients with additional cartilage damage. (Schimmer RC, Arthroscopy 1998;14:136).
  • Mensical Repair
  • Meniscal Transplantation
  • Discoid Meniscus

Meniscal Tear Associated Injuries / Differential Diagnosis

  • Knee Arthritis
  • LCL, Posterolateral cornercombined injury
  • MCL: need for concurrent repair is dependent on amount of valgus laxity.  2-3mm increased laxity is probably not detrimental.  Absolute indication for MCL repair has not been established.
  • Chondral injury.
  • PCL tear
  • ACL tear: Shelbourne’s showed a decrease in post operative loss of extension in patients treated with meniscal repair followed by delayed ACL reconstruction compared to those treated with simultaneous repairs for patients with locked bucket-handle meniscal tears and chronic ACL deficiency. (Shelbourne KD Am J Sports Med 1993;21:779). Isolated stable tears of the posterior horn of the lateral meniscus posterior to the popliteus can be left untreated during ACL reconstruction.
  • Patellar Dislocation
  • Popliteus avulsion
  • Knee Dislocation
  • Tumor (Muscolo DL, JBJS 2003;85A:1209).
  • Discoid Meniscus

Meniscal Repair Complications

  • Overall complication rate = 1.8% (Small NC, Arthroscopy 1988;3:215)
  • DVT: 9.9%, proximal DVT rate = 2.1% (Ilahi OA, Arthroscopy, 2005;21:727)
  • Stiffness / Arthrofibrosis
  • Chondral Injury / Arthritis
  • Infection
  • NVI (medial = saphenous neuralgia, lateral = peronela nerve palsy)
  • Fluid Extravastion / Compartment Syndrome
  • Complex Regional Pain Syndrome: rare
  • Hemarthrosis
  • Synovial fistula
  • DVT, Stiffness / Arthrofibrosis, Chondral Injury / Arthritis, Infection, NVI (medial = saphenous neuralgia, lateral = peronela nerve palsy), Fluid Extravastion / Compartment Syndrome, Complex Regional Pain Syndrome, Hemarthrosis, Synovial fistula

Meniscal Repair Follow-up

  • 80-90% successful.
  • Hinged-knee brace with 0 to 90° of motion, 25% weight bearing with crutches for 4 wks.
  • Full weight bearing and flexion beyond 90° usually is allowed after 6 to 12 weeks postoperatively.
  • Squating is prohibited for 4 months.
  • Patients may return to sedentary work at 1 week, strenuous work at 3 to 4 months, low-impact exercises at 8 weeks, and running after 4 to 5 months. Light or moderate sports are allowed at 6 to 9 months.

Meniscal Tear Review References




The information on this website is intended for orthopaedic surgeons.  It is not intended for the general public. The information on this website may not be complete or accurate.  The eORIF website is not an authoritative reference for orthopaedic surgery or medicine and does not represent the "standard of care".  While the information on this site is about health care issues and sports medicine, it is not medical advice. People seeking specific medical advice or assistance should contact a board certified physician.  See Site Terms / Full Disclaimer